Business and commercial litigation is a dynamic field where disputes over contracts, business practices, and intellectual property can have an impact on businesses and professionals alike. Drawing insights from the 2024 Lex Machina Contracts: Commercial Litigation Report, this post spotlights five trends that have been shaping the litigation landscape, providing valuable insights to protect your business interests and navigate high-stakes disputes effectively.

1. Breach of Contract: The Dominant Litigation Trend

Breach of contract disputes are the foundation of business and commercial litigation, with a notable 15% increase in cases during 2023, reflecting a recovery from pandemic-related declines. These disputes frequently involve issues like payment failures, service deficiencies, or non-compliance with agreed terms.

Key Statistics:

Claimants succeeded three times more often than defendants.
Success rates were often linked to clear and enforceable written agreements.

Takeaways for Claimants:

Draft contracts that are precise, detailed, and enforceable.
Act swiftly to preserve evidence and pursue claims effectively.

Takeaways for Defendants:

Conduct regular contract reviews to minimize risk.
Seek early procedural dismissals when claims lack merit.

This trend underscores the importance of proactive contract management and tailored legal strategies for both sides.

2. Non-Compete and Trade Secret Litigation: Safeguarding Business Assets

Disputes involving non-compete agreements and trade secrets are important for businesses aiming to protect proprietary information and maintain their competitive edge. These cases can be highstakes, with significant financial and reputational implications.

Key Statistics:

Non-compete cases have averaged 600 filings annually over the past decade.
Nearly half of these cases also included trade-secret claims.
Courts assess enforceability based on reasonableness and jurisdictional standards.

Takeaways for Businesses:

Draft non-compete agreements tailored to specific roles and compliant with jurisdictional requirements.
Invest in robust security measures to safeguard trade secrets.

Takeaways for Employees:

Familiarize yourself with the limits of non-compete clauses in your jurisdiction to avoid potential disputes.

The complexity and importance of these disputes demand a proactive approach, ensuring that all parties understand their rights and obligations to protect their interests effectively.

3. Tortious Interference: Protecting Business Relationships

Tortious interference claims arise when a third party is accused of improperly disrupting an existing contract or business relationship. These cases can be challenging to prove but serve as an essential legal remedy for businesses facing unwarranted harm.

Key Statistics:

Courts ruled in favor of defendants in over 600 cases, highlighting the difficulty of proving unjustified interference.
Successful claims often relied on compelling evidence demonstrating malicious intent.

Takeaways for Plaintiffs:

Establish that the interference lacked justification and directly resulted in measurable harm.

Takeaways for Defendants:

Provide evidence of a legitimate business rationale for the actions in question to refute the claim.

Navigating tortious interference claims requires a deep understanding of the legal principles involved, as well as meticulous preparation to present or defend against allegations effectively. A strategic approach is critical to safeguarding or asserting business interests in these complex disputes.

4. Conversion Claims: Disputes Over Ownership

Conversion claims arise when there is an allegation of unauthorized possession or use of property. These disputes frequently occur in high-stakes business scenarios involving contested ownership of assets or intellectual property.

Key Statistics:

Courts ruled in favor of claimants in 154 cases.
More than 240 claims were dismissed due to insufficient evidence.
Common disputes involve inventory, financial assets, or proprietary information.

Takeaways for Plaintiffs:

Provide clear documentation of ownership and establish evidence of unauthorized possession or use.

Takeaways for Defendants:

Argue rightful possession or demonstrate the absence of intent to deprive the rightful owner.

Success in conversion cases often hinges on comprehensive evidence and a well-prepared legal strategy, making meticulous documentation and a strong understanding of the law indispensable.

5. Fraud and Misrepresentation: High Stakes, High Complexity

Fraud and misrepresentation cases are less frequent than contract disputes but carry reputational and financial risks. These claims are complex, requiring strong evidence of intent and reliance. As a result, they are significantly more challenging to litigate than standard contract disputes.

Key Statistics:

Courts ruled "No Fraud" in more than 640 cases between 2021 and 2023,
double the number of cases where fraud was successfully proven.
Successful claims often depended on strong, well-documented evidence and clear communication of the harm caused.

Takeaways for Claimants:

Assemble a comprehensive case backed by concrete documentation of deceit and reliance.

Takeaways for Defendants:

Rigorously challenge the sufficiency and credibility of the evidence presented.
Emphasize legitimate business practices to undermine the plaintiff's arguments.

The high-stakes and intricate nature of these cases necessitate thorough preparation, attention to detail, and a carefully crafted legal strategy to navigate the complexities and secure a favorable outcome.

What This Means for Business Owners, Executives, and Professionals

The evolving trends in commercial litigation underscore its complexity and dynamic nature. For businesses and high-income professionals managing substantial financial interests, understanding these disputes and preparing effectively for potential litigation can be pivotal to protecting and advancing your goals.

Practical Takeaways:

Be proactive: Regularly review and fortify contracts, agreements, and internal controls to mitigate risks before they arise.
Invest in legal counsel: Partner with experienced litigators who can identify vulnerabilities, navigate disputes, and help secure favorable outcomes.
Act swiftly: Timely action—whether pursuing a claim or mounting a defense—often results in stronger positions and better resolutions.

Navigating business and commercial litigation successfully requires more than just legal knowledge; it demands foresight, strategic planning, and decisive action. By staying informed and collaborating with skilled legal professionals, you can protect your assets, safeguard your reputation, and preserve critical business relationships in today’s increasingly litigious landscape.

If you are facing challenges related to these litigation trends, we invite you to schedule a consultation with us to address your specific needs and explore customized strategies to safeguard and strengthen your business interests. Contact us at (585) 294-0303 or visit our website to arrange your consultation today. We are ready to help you preserve what you have earned and obtain a resolution while maintaining your principles so you can secure your future.

You can also learn more about us and how we operate by visiting these pages: About Us, What Sets Us Apart.

This post is not intended as legal advice, but rather for educational purposes.